| |
If more or less, three humors cause disease,
the learned count the wind is the first of these.'
- Medicine, Thirukkural
|
| |
|
| |
The
various aspects of epilepsy have been viewed based on the etiology,
pathology and treatment by holistic approaches. The three main systems
of Indian medicines, Siddha, Ayurveda and Unani have defined their
respective orthodox approaches in the diagnosis and treatment of
epilepsy. |
| |
Siddha system
Ayurveda system
Unani system |
| |
The
Indian systems of medicine are based on empirical medicine .The
wisdom of our ancients who delved into the mysteries of the human
body, observed meticulously and prepared medication following the
treasure formulae with utmost precision have given us a trove of
knowledge. Modern research into these Indian systems of medicine
is being pursued all over the country. Isolating the active ingredients,
for example alkaloids of many plant based formulations, has been
successful and lead to a better understanding of the how these medications
may work. Much research is on going.
|
| |
While these
Indian systems offer alternative approaches, the evidence base for
their utility is still questionable in the modern context. It is
important that patients do not switch from one system of medicine
to another at random.
Allopathy has several advantages at present:
|
| |
|
It offers several
technological tools to diagnose and treat epilepsy |
|
|
Recently developed anti-convulsants
are tailored to target specific chemical systems in the brain |
| |
|
Brain stimulation procedures
and epilepsy surgery are viable alternatives for intractable seizure
disorder |
| |
However, as
allopathy does not necessarily have all the answers, and Epilepsy
continues to disrupt the social functioning, our awareness about
alternative systems in our own culture is important, and merits
further exploration. |
| |
|
| |
Siddha system
|
| |
The origin
of the Tamil language is attributed to sage Agasthya and the siddha
system of medicine is an accolade to his expertise. This form of
medicine has been noted since 5th - 6th B.C.It is a practiced system
of medicine to this day.
Since the evolution of this medicine seizures and epilepsy have
been noted and treated. The Siddha classifies epilepsy into 5 major
types: |
| |
|
Kumarakandam - an
affliction named after hornless animals. |
| |
|
Amarakandam - disorder
with ghastly features like hell. |
| |
|
Bhramakandam - characterized
by prolonged stupor. |
| |
|
Kakkai vali - named
after the crow. |
| |
|
Muyal vali - named
after the demon, on whom Lord Shiva performs his dance to destroy
the evil forces |
| |
|
| |
Description
of symptoms associated with each of the above-mentioned types of
epilepsy. |
| |
|
| |
The sickness
of the three pains/Kumarakandam: This affliction comprises of unending
stomachache followed by diminution of vision with protrusion of
tongue and distortion of lower jaw. There is stiffening of the neck
due to severe pain around the shoulders. The features are attributed
to the three humors, namely the Vat, Pitha, and Kapha. |
| |
|
| |
Amarakandam:
In this disorder there is restlessness due to a nagging pain and
itching associated with increased perspiration and respiration.
Sometimes the illness is so severe in form that the patient almost
like a corpse, numb with pain. This experience is compared with
a hellish experience.
|
| |
Bhramakandam
(Kurangu vali) : The limbs are flaccid. The patient strains his
muscles with the pain, clenches his/her teeth and it is associated
with photophobia. The eyes are set staring lifelessly. The doctor
invariably pronounces poor prognosis after examining the pulse in
this condition. This condition is attributed to the foul interplay
of the three humors. |
| |
|
| |
Kakkai vali:
This disease seizes the victim faster than the wind and extinguishes
his life like Yama, the God of death. The features, which help to
identify the victim of this illness, are: the eyes will be widely
open with a constant upward gaze. The patient has double. |
| |
|
| |
Ayurveda system
|
| |
|
| |
Apasmara is
the synonym for epilepsy in ayurveda. It is considered as a disorder
due to derangements of intellect and the mind characterized by loss
of memory, loss of consciousness and convulsive movements of the
body. On the basis of doshsas [humors] there are four kinds of apasmaras.
|
| |
1. Vataja Apasmara
2. Pittaja Apasmara
3. Kaphaja Apasmara
4. Sannipataja Apasmara |
| |
|
| |
Symptoms of Endogenous or Humoral Apasmaras
|
| |
| Vataja |
Pittaja |
Kaphaja |
| Nails, face, skin and eyes are
red & dusky |
They are ginger like green or coppery |
They are found in white or Pale
in colour |
| Dribbling of frothy saliva from
mouth |
Stertorous breathing |
Drooling of saliva from angle of
mouth |
| Head drawn to one side, clenching
of fingers and feet |
Tossing on the ground |
Falling on the ground. No strong
convulsive movements are seen |
| Frequent attacks of transient unconsciousness
followed by immediate regaining of consciousness |
Frequent attacks similar to vattaja |
Slowly becoming unconscious and
regaining consciousness |
| Visual aura of jerky, fickle harsh
& dry red objects |
Visual aura of blood fierce terrifying,
blazing & angry looking forms & of non-homologation
of pitta causing factors |
Visual aura of white hairy and
glossy shapes & homologation of antagonistic kapha humor
|
|
| |
|
| |
The Sanni Pataja
apasmara is called incurable due to the combination of imbalance
in all the three humors. The symptoms are usually atypical and this
apasmara usually has a bad prognosis. The vata type of epilepsy
is treated by means of basic (the enemata), pittava epilepsy is
treated mainly by virecana (the purgation) and kapha type of epilepsy
mainly by vamana (the emesis). As preventive measures morality and
mental tranquility are advised. Existing psychic causes which can
trigger an attack like worry anxiety, greed, grief, passion should
be avoided. |
| |
|
| |
Unani system
|
| |
|
| |
This system
became popular during the Muslim rule of the country and continues
to be practiced to this day in India. Najabuddin Unhammad (1222
AD) made a special study of mental diseases and described 7 varieties
of illness. The treatment usually consists of purging and blood
letting along with nutritious diet. According to the Unani system
of medicine, epilepsy is mainly due to the vicious humor accumulating
in the blood. |
| |
|
| |
Based on this
theory there are 4 humors |
| |
|
| |
(i) Dum (sanguine
blood)
(ii) Balgham (phlegm)
(iii) Safra (yellow bile)
(iv) Sauda (black bile)
|
| |
The humoral
balance plays a vital role in the maintenance of health. Epilepsy
is due to a block (sudda) in the roots of the nerves in the brain
due to the accumulation of these humors. In treatment, after the
patient recovers from the acute stage, the cause is identified and
treatment is directed towards the causative humor. In case of excessive
sanguine humor, specific venisection and cupping is suggested. |
| |
Usually the
first line of management is purgative medicines and cleansing agents
like Jadwar-Ood-E-Salaib
Khamir-E-Abresham-Harim-Arshadwala are used. Sometimes even sneezing
is induced. As anticonvulsant therapy, hot oil massages with the
following oils are prescribed: Roghan-E-Surkh, Roghan-E-Baboona
etc.
|
| |
As an antiepileptic,
Dana-Us-Shifa is given with 120 ml of cow's milk. Finally brain
& neural health tonics like Itherifal-Usta-Khudoos, Dawa-Ul-Misk
and Muatidil Jawahar Wali are given to nourish the neural tissue. |